SIDM · APPENDIX
Appendix III — Four-Stage Review Checkpoints
Each checkpoint produces approved , conditionally approved , or returned , with records of object/version, specialist confirmation, authorized decision,…
| Stage | Principal outputs | Questions to confirm |
|---|---|---|
| Design Inputs and Direction | Design Direction Definition, source versions, risks, approvals | Are objectives, tasks, perceptions, brand, manufacture, budget, and boundaries clear? |
| Concept and Exterior Design Definition | Concepts, confirmed exterior direction, CMF, manufacturing hypotheses, verification plan | Has the integrated standard been used? Are core objectives and risks explicit? Have necessary reviews/rechecks taken place? |
| Process Assessment and Structural Definition | Structure, process/manufacturing basis, standards, specialist confirmations | Has design intent survived? Are technical conditions and process risks confirmed? |
| Manufacturing Collaboration and Physical Delivery | First articles, assembly, four-perspective and site checks, delivery issues | Has this project fulfilled its design intent? Have shipping, installation, and issues been closed appropriately? |
Each checkpoint produces approved, conditionally approved, or returned, with records of object/version, specialist confirmation, authorized decision, unresolved issues, restrictions, and closure requirements. Return to earlier work only within the evidenced impact range. Changes in core objectives, cost, schedule, or professional requirements may require renewed approval.
Apply the four perspectives alongside the reviews. Recognition at a Glance verifies overall expression and attribution. Quality Up Close inspects physical outcomes. Interaction at the Point of Use checks real tasks. Tracing Back to Manufacturing identifies the structure, processes, resources, supply, assembly, quality control, and conditions for repeating the result. At concept stage these are hypotheses and planned tests; realization evidence requires appropriate samples, first articles, or physical equipment.
Moving Risk Forward — 1:10:100 is an experiential reminder that problems discovered later may affect more completed work. It is not a project cost formula or a claim of fixed multiples between stages. Where the first machine is the delivery machine, use proportionate local samples, first-article checks, and specialist verification. Project delivery verifies the current project; Brand Equity requires evidence from continued use and subsequent work.
KEEP READING





































