← All methodology chapters

SIDM · APPENDIX

Appendix

Appendix II — Five-Dimension, Three-Level Maturity Matrix and Conditions of Use

Use this matrix only with Chapter 9 and the dimension-specific necessary conditions in Chapters 11–15. Assign each dimension the highest level fully…

Published Updated
Appendix II — Five-Dimension, Three-Level Maturity Matrix and Conditions of Use
Assessment dimension Level 1 — Foundational Expression Level 2 — System-Building Level 3 — Brand Equity
Brand Recognition Recognition through explicit brand marks Recognition through product language Recognition through brand DNA
Quality Expression Basic manufacturing presentation Systematic quality development Shared confidence in brand quality
Interaction Experience Basic touchpoint usability Coherent system interaction Established brand experience expectations
Product Family Development Basic individual-product presentation Consistent product-family language Product-system assets; no requirement for multiple formally named series
Business Value Monetization of functional specifications, supported by actual sale and corresponding fulfillment Competitive trust advantage Compounding returns from brand equity

Use this matrix only with Chapter 9 and the dimension-specific necessary conditions in Chapters 11–15. Assign each dimension the highest level fully satisfied. Do not average scores. Advanced evidence cannot compensate for missing foundational requirements. Level 1 asks whether the qualifying result exists; Level 2 whether a repeatable system exists; Level 3 whether past outcomes have become effective future-facing assets.

Business Value Level 1 requires a real sale and corresponding fulfillment. If there is only a procurement comparison, record “Transactional foundations established; monetization outcome pending verification.” Do not confirm Level 1 or use partial higher-level evidence to bypass this gate.

Product-System Assets depend on sustained reuse, adaptation, evolution, and actual benefit to subsequent products. One specialized product family may achieve them through later models, client projects, and iterations. Multiple formal product series are not a prerequisite.

Dimension Evaluation object Evidence emphasis
Brand Recognition Equipment, product family, customer perception Attribution, expression rules, repeated execution, associations with enterprise values
Quality Expression Physical units, batches, projects, use Results, standards, causal tracing, external quality expectations
Interaction Experience Tasks, touchpoints, users, context Real behavior, repeated rules, transfer of experience
Product Family Development Actual product family and subsequent products/models/projects Consistency, adaptation, reuse, evolution, practical benefit; no formal-series-count minimum
Business Value Enterprise, customers, business process Actual sale and fulfillment; observable design contribution; other influences

Evidence falls into five categories: outcomes, rules, execution, external, and business. Level 2 requires outcome + rule + repeated execution; neither tacit personal expertise nor an unused document establishes a system. Level 3 requires recurrence + continuity + asset value, generally supported by external evidence. SIDM does not mandate an arbitrary observation period in years.

Project assessment may describe achieved features and the foundation for a level. Enterprise maturity integrates multiple products, projects, deliveries, real user/customer responses, and evidence over time. One successful project cannot automatically establish enterprise Brand Equity.

The three auxiliary states are Below foundational conditions, Insufficient evidence, and Not currently applicable. The last requires genuine inapplicability with an explained scope: “we have not done it yet” is not the same as “not applicable.” When evidence conflicts, prioritize physical equipment, observed behavior, actual use, and sustained delivery, checking comparability first.

The output is a five-dimension maturity profile specifying object and observation period, level, evidence, gaps, objectives, corrective action, responsible role, and reassessment date. Competitive Trust Advantage can be demonstrated through understanding, trust, and defensible value explanation; price increases are not its only measure. No higher-level evidence allows bypassing the base transaction-and-fulfillment requirement.

KEEP READING

Continue Exploring the Methodology

View all chapters →